[[Sstc]]
== "Sstc" Extension for Supervisor-mode Timer Interrupts, Version 1.0.0

The current Privileged arch specification only defines a hardware mechanism for
generating machine-mode timer interrupts (based on the mtime and mtimecmp
registers). With the resultant requirement that timer services for
S-mode/HS-mode (and for VS-mode) have to all be provided by M-mode - via SBI
calls from S/HS-mode up to M-mode (or VS-mode calls to HS-mode and then to
M-mode). M-mode software then multiplexes these multiple logical timers onto
its one physical M-mode timer facility, and the M-mode timer interrupt handler
passes timer interrupts back down to the appropriate lower privilege mode.

This extension serves to provide supervisor mode with its own CSR-based timer
interrupt facility that it can directly manage to provide its own timer service
(in the form of having its own stimecmp register) - thus eliminating the large
overheads for emulating S/HS-mode timers and timer interrupt generation up in
M-mode. Further, this extension adds a similar facility to the Hypervisor
extension for VS-mode.

To make it easy to understand the deltas from the current Priv 1.11/1.12 specs,
this is written as the actual exact changes to be made to existing paragraphs
of Priv spec text (or additional paragraphs within the existing text).

The extension name is "Sstc" ('Ss' for Privileged arch and Supervisor-level
extensions, and 'tc' for timecmp). This extension adds the S-level stimecmp CSR
and the VS-level vstimecmp CSR.

=== Machine and Supervisor Level Additions

==== *Supervisor Timer Register (stimecmp)*

This extension adds this new CSR.

The stimecmp CSR is a 64-bit register and has 64-bit precision on all RV32 and
RV64 systems. In RV32 only, accesses to the stimecmp CSR access the low 32
bits, while accesses to the stimecmph CSR access the high 32 bits of stimecmp.

The CSR numbers for stimecmp / stimecmph are 0x14D / 0x15D (within the
Supervisor Trap Setup block of CSRs).

A supervisor timer interrupt becomes pending - as reflected in the STIP bit in
the mip and sip registers - whenever time contains a value greater than or
equal to stimecmp, treating the values as unsigned integers. Writes to stimecmp
are guaranteed to be reflected in STIP eventually, but not necessarily
immediately. The interrupt remains posted until stimecmp becomes greater than
time - typically as a result of writing stimecmp. The interrupt will be taken
based on the standard interrupt enable and delegation rules.

[NOTE]
.Non-normative
====
A spurious timer interrupt might occur if an interrupt handler advances
stimecmp then immediately returns, because STIP might not yet have fallen in
the interim. All software should be written to assume this event is possible,
but most software should assume this event is extremely unlikely. It is almost
always more performant to incur an occasional spurious timer interrupt than to
poll STIP until it falls.
====

[NOTE]
.Non-normative
====
In systems in which a supervisor execution environment (SEE) provides timer
facilities via an SBI function call, this SBI call will continue to support
requests to schedule a timer interrupt. The SEE will simply make use of
stimecmp, changing its value as appropriate. This ensures compatibility with
existing S-mode software that uses this SEE facility, while new S-mode software
takes advantage of stimecmp directly.)
====

==== Machine Interrupt Registers (mip and mie)

This extension modifies the description of the STIP/STIE bits in these
registers as follows:

If supervisor mode is implemented, its mip.STIP and mie.STIE are the
interrupt-pending and interrupt-enable bits for supervisor-level timer
interrupts. If the stimecmp register is not implemented, STIP is writable in
mip, and may be written by M-mode software to deliver timer interrupts to
S-mode. If the stimecmp (supervisor-mode timer compare) register is
implemented, STIP is read-only in mip and reflects the supervisor-level timer
interrupt signal resulting from stimecmp. This timer interrupt signal is
cleared by writing stimecmp with a value greater than the current time value.

==== Supervisor Interrupt Registers (sip and sie)

This extension modifies the description of the STIP/STIE bits in these
registers as follows:

Bits sip.STIP and sie.STIE are the interrupt-pending and interrupt-enable bits
for supervisor level timer interrupts. If implemented, STIP is read-only in
sip, and is either set and cleared by the execution environment (if stimecmp is
not implemented), or reflects the timer interrupt signal resulting from
stimecmp (if stimecmp is implemented). The sip.STIP bit, in response to timer
interrupts generated by stimecmp, is set and cleared by writing stimecmp with a
value that respectively is less than or equal to, or greater than, the current
time value.

==== Machine Counter-Enable Register (mcounteren)

This extension adds to the description of the TM bit in this register as
follows:

In addition, when the TM bit in the mcounteren register is clear, attempts to
access the stimecmp or vstimecmp register while executing in a mode less
privileged than M will cause an illegal instruction exception.  When this bit
is set, access to the stimecmp or vstimecmp register is permitted in S-mode if
implemented, and access to the vstimecmp register (via stimecmp) is permitted
in VS-mode if implemented and not otherwise prevented by the TM bit in
hcounteren.

=== Hypervisor Extension Additions

==== *Virtual Supervisor Timer Register (vstimecmp)*

This extension adds this new CSR.

The vstimecmp CSR is a 64-bit register and has 64-bit precision on all RV32 and
RV64 systems. In RV32 only, accesses to the vstimecmp CSR access the low 32
bits, while accesses to the vstimecmph CSR access the high 32 bits of
vstimecmp.

The proposed CSR numbers for vstimecmp / vstimecmph are 0x24D / 0x25D (within
the Virtual Supervisor Registers block of CSRs, and mirroring the CSR numbers
for stimecmp/stimecmph).

A virtual supervisor timer interrupt becomes pending - as reflected in the
VSTIP bit in the hip register - whenever (time + htimedelta), truncated to 64
bits, contains a value greater than or equal to vstimecmp, treating the values
as unsigned integers. Writes to vstimecmp and htimedelta are guaranteed to be
reflected in VSTIP eventually, but not necessarily immediately. The interrupt
remains posted until vstimecmp becomes greater than (time + htimedelta) -
typically as a result of writing vstimecmp. The interrupt will be taken based
on the standard interrupt enable and delegation rules while V=1.

[NOTE]
.Non-normative
====
In systems in which a supervisor execution environment (SEE) implemented by an
HS-mode hypervisor provides timer facilities via an SBI function call, this SBI
call will continue to support requests to schedule a timer interrupt. The SEE
will simply make use of vstimecmp, changing its value as appropriate. This
ensures compatibility with existing guest VS-mode software that uses this SEE
facility, while new VS-mode software takes advantage of vstimecmp directly.)
====

==== Hypervisor Interrupt Registers (hvip, hip, and hie)

This extension modifies the description of the VSTIP/VSTIE bits in the hip/hie
registers as follows:

Bits hip.VSTIP and hie.VSTIE are the interrupt-pending and interrupt-enable
bits for VS-level timer interrupts. VSTIP is read-only in hip, and is the
logical-OR of hvip.VSTIP and the timer interrupt signal resulting from
vstimecmp (if vstimecmp is implemented). The hip.VSTIP bit, in response to
timer interrupts generated by vstimecmp, is set and cleared by writing
vstimecmp with a value that respectively is less than or equal to, or greater
than, the current (time + htimedelta) value. The hip.VSTIP bit remains defined
while V=0 as well as V=1.

==== Hypervisor Counter-Enable Register (hcounteren)

This extension adds to the description of the TM bit in this register as
follows:

In addition, when the TM bit in the hcounteren register is clear, attempts to
access the vstimecmp register (via stimecmp) while executing in VS-mode will
cause a virtual instruction exception if the same bit in mcounteren is set.
When this bit and the same bit in mcounteren are both set, access to the
vstimecmp register (if implemented) is permitted in VS-mode.

=== Environment Config (menvcfg/henvcfg) Support

Enable/disable bits for this extension are provided in the new menvcfg /
henvcfg CSRs.

Bit 63 of menvcfg (or bit 31 of menvcfgh) - named STCE (STimecmp Enable) -
enables stimecmp for S-mode when set to one, and the same bit of henvcfg
enables vstimecmp for VS-mode. These STCE bits are WARL and are hard-wired to 0
when this extension is not implemented.

When this extension is implemented and STCE in menvcfg is zero, an attempt to access stimecmp or vstimecmp in a
mode other than M-mode raises an illegal instruction exception, STCE in henvcfg
is read-only zero, and STIP in mip and sip reverts to its defined behavior as
if this extension is not implemented. Further, if the H extension is implemented, then hip.VSTIP also reverts its defined behavior as if this extension is not implemented.

But when STCE in menvcfg is one and STCE in henvcfg is zero, an attempt to access
stimecmp (really vstimecmp) when V = 1 raises a virtual instruction exception,
and VSTIP in hip reverts to its defined behavior as if this extension is not
implemented.
